Written by: Jeanie Chang
generalforum.com
Have you ever received criticism on your parenting skills from some
random person or received unsolicited advice from a stranger about your
child? Or maybe it wasn’t a comment, but more like a look that spoke
louder than words? I just read a very interesting blog: http://parenting.blogs.nytimes.com.
It’s written by a woman who wrote an article for the University of
Baltimore Law Review about “how the tendency to judge mothering harshly
plays out for the poor and minority women who come under scrutiny of
the child welfare system.”
She adapted this article into a blog for The New York Times and it really got me thinking. You’ll need to read the blog before understanding what I have to say, but I can see her point. I have been on both sides of what she’s talking about. What I mean is, I was the one judging the parents of a child and I also received judgment from someone else after I became a mother. Before having kids, I looked at the parents who had their toddlers on those kiddie leashes in GREAT disdain. I remember thinking it was pretty much close to child abuse as you can get and I couldn’t believe the parents were walking around in public holding their child on a leash! I learned to eat my words later when I considered getting one myself to control my active son who would run anywhere at any place any chance he got. I completely understood the reason behind those kiddie leashes!
On the flip side, I have received a few jabs here and there about my parenting “skills” from random people. The most blatant by far was the first comment I received after having my first child. I was walking my daughter who at the time was two months old in her stroller around the mall and she was napping peacefully on her tummy. I know you’re not supposed to sleep your baby on your tummy, but my daughter preferred sleeping on her tummy. Anyways, I was in the elevator and a woman (maybe in her sixties) turned to me and practically snapped my head off. She told me the baby should be sleeping on her back and if the baby’s mother knew what I was doing, I’d be in ‘big trouble!’ Obviously, she thought I was a nanny or babysitter. Anyways, I had to practically hold her back from flipping my daughter over onto her back. It was a nasty encounter and that left me somewhat scarred for days. Being a first-time mom and all, I was very sensitive. If that happened now, I’d definitely have a witty comeback. J Since then, I have received looks or snide comments here and there about random things I was doing with my kids. I’m sure you’ve had that experience as well. What have you done about it?
The author of this blog, Chris Gottlieb knows what she’s talking about. She’s with the Family Defense Clinic at New York University School of Law and represents parents accused of child abuse and neglect and tries to keep families together. She points out that those who are in the position to make judgment on the parents accused of child abuse and neglect (in many cases, mainly the poor and minority parents) have such impossibly high standards that it’s going to set the parents up for failure no matter what. Of course she is in no way diminishing the fact that there are cases where the child (ren) must be removed from their parents for their well-being. But she’s saying we all need to reevaluate our tendency to approaching parenting with such “unforgiving” eyes. Gottlieb goes on to say that the children would be better off if everyone viewed parenting by strangers the same as we view parenting by our friends and families – “generously” and without such a critical eye. I really like this statement. What are your thoughts on her blog?
Written by: Jeanie Chang